Skip to content
TMAC Properties Lake LBJ · Port A · Austin
Mustang Island beach in Port Aransas, Texas

Compare · Gulf coast or Hill Country

Port Aransas vs Lake LBJ — beach or lake?

Beach, golf cart, and pool on Mustang Island, or a private dock, lake days, and a spa in Kingsland. Here’s how our homes compare.

By TMAC Properties

It’s the question we hear most: the beach or the lake? Both trips are owner-operated by TMAC Properties and booked direct with no guest service fee. Here’s the honest difference, using only what’s true of our homes.

Side by side

Port Aransas beach on Mustang IslandStay Beautiful’s private dock on Lake LBJ in Kingsland
Port AransasLake LBJ (Kingsland)
SettingMustang Island beach town on the GulfConstant-level Hill Country lake
HomesPierce’s Paradise · Dog Days of SummerStay Beautiful
Sleeps10 (Pierce’s) · 14 (Dog Days) · 24 together12
Bedrooms3 bed · 2.5 bath (Pierce’s) · 5 bed · 4 bath (Dog Days)4 bed · 3 bath
WaterPrivate pool at each home; pool heat add-on $125/dayPrivate dock with 2 lift spots; paddleboard and floating mat
Golf cart6-seater included at each homeNo
Private dockNoYes
Rainy-day / eveningDog Days’ Crow’s Nest rooftop for sunsetsCovered spa · Graham’s game room (pool table, arcade)
PetsUp to 2 house-trained dogsUp to 2 house-trained dogs

Facts from each home’s page as of Oct 10, 2026. Live calendar and totals are in each home’s booking widget.

Choose Port Aransas if…

Beach, golf cart, pool

  • You want the Gulf: golf cart to the beach and to dinner, no parking hunt.
  • Kids want a private pool at the house, not a shared-complex pool.
  • You need room for a big group: book both Port A houses, a short golf cart ride apart, to sleep 24.
  • You’re planning around an island weekend. See Port Aransas events.

Port Aransas homes →

Choose Lake LBJ if…

Dock, lake, spa

  • You’re bringing or renting a boat: private dock with 2 lift spots.
  • You want lake days: paddleboard and floating mat off the dock.
  • Cooler nights matter: covered spa after sunset, game room for downtime.
  • The lake is constant-level, so the view from the dock stays put.

Lake LBJ home →

By season

Fall: after Labor Day, boat traffic on Lake LBJ drops and the water stays warm into October; Port A’s shoulder weeks mean easier parking and the same houses. Winter: spa and game room on the lake; pool heat and Crow’s Nest sunsets on the island. Spring break fills Port A first. When to go →

Stay Beautiful·Pierce’s Paradise·Dog Days of Summer·Check dates →

Planning questions

  • Port Aransas if you want the beach, a private pool, and a golf cart included. Lake LBJ if you want a private dock, lake days, a covered spa, and a game room. Both homes welcome up to 2 house-trained dogs.

Ask the owners

A person answers — not a ticket queue.
Email us